Usually not the messages themselves. Carriers handle two different kinds of data: records about a text, such as the phone numbers involved and the date and time, and the content of the text. How long a carrier keeps either one varies by carrier and changes over time, so you should not count on content existing at all. iMessage, RCS chats in Google Messages and WhatsApp are end-to-end encrypted, so the carrier never had readable content to begin with. And even when a provider does hold content, federal law sharply limits who it can give it to. For most people, the realistic source of old messages is the phone, the other person's phone, and backups.
Metadata versus content
Metadata is the record that a communication happened: which numbers, when, and sometimes which cell site handled it. Content is what the message said. These are treated very differently, both by carriers in practice and by the law. A carrier's records may be able to show that your number exchanged messages with another number on a given day without showing a single word of what was said.
Why many messages never pass through the carrier as text
Much of what people think of as texting does not travel as a traditional carrier text message at all.
- iMessage. Apple says it does not store iMessage content or attachments and that they are secured with end-to-end encryption, so no one but the sender and receiver can access them and Apple cannot decrypt the data. To the carrier, an iMessage is just encrypted internet traffic.
- RCS in Google Messages. Google says RCS conversations between Google Messages users are end-to-end encrypted by default, and that neither Google nor other third parties can read them because they do not have the key. Google also notes that end-to-end encryption is not available for SMS and MMS.
- WhatsApp and similar apps. WhatsApp says no one outside the chat, not even WhatsApp, can read end-to-end encrypted messages.
Only plain SMS and MMS, the green bubble texts between an iPhone and many other phones, run through the carrier's own messaging system. Those are the only messages where carrier content is even a question.
Subpoenas and legal process
The federal Stored Communications Act generally prohibits providers from knowingly disclosing the contents of communications. Its exceptions include disclosure with the consent of the sender or an intended recipient, but an ordinary civil subpoena is not on the list. Records that are not content, such as subscriber information, are treated differently, and the statute allows them to be disclosed to a person other than a government entity. That is why civil cases usually seek carrier records, not carrier content.
Law enforcement uses separate procedures under the same law, and in Carpenter v. United States (2018) the Supreme Court held that the government generally needs a warrant to obtain historical cell site location records from a carrier. If you need carrier records for a case, talk to your attorney early about preservation letters and the right form of legal process, because retention is limited.
The device and backups are the realistic source
The phones in the conversation are where message content actually lives, and they often hold more than people expect.
- Recently Deleted on iPhone. On iOS 16 and later, Apple says you can recover messages and conversations deleted within the last 30 to 40 days from the Recently Deleted page in Messages.
- Backups. Apple says that when Messages in iCloud is off, your messages are included in iCloud Backup; when it is on, messages sync to iCloud instead. Computer backups and older phones can also hold history.
- The other person's phone. A message deleted on one phone often still exists on the other. Access should come through agreement, discovery or a court order, not by logging in to someone else's device or account.
- Forensic extraction. An examination of the phone can recover active messages, attachments and, depending on the device, records of deleted messages that remain in the message database.
Our articles on recovering deleted text messages and authenticating text messages in California go deeper on both steps.
What to do now
- Do not delete conversations, reset the phone or restore a backup.
- Note which accounts the phone backs up to and whether Messages in iCloud is on.
- Ask your attorney about preservation letters to the carrier and the other party right away.
- Rely on a forensic extraction for evidence, not just screenshots.
If the messages involve threats or harassment and you are in danger, call 911. Police can use legal process that private parties cannot. The National Domestic Violence Hotline (1-800-799-7233) can help you plan safely, ideally from a device the other person has never had access to.
How we help
We preserve and extract messages from phones and backups, recover deleted records where the device allows, analyze carrier records alongside the device data, and explain the results in reports and testimony for attorneys and individuals. We work remotely with clients anywhere in the U.S. and on-site in San Diego County.
Related services
More articles
- Recovering Deleted Text Messages with Digital Forensics
- Authenticating Text Messages in California: What Courts Look For
- Digital Evidence in California Domestic Violence Restraining Orders
This article is general information, not legal advice. Every matter is different; contact the examiner to discuss yours.
